Yeah, good luck with that, Church dissenters

With the pope soon to step down (supposedly, it’s not technically a resignation, but for all intents and purposes it is), all the usual suspects are gathering to suggest the Vatican follow man and not, say, God.

Por ejemplo:

“The leadership of our church needs to be in touch with the signs of our times,” said Janet Hauter, chair of the progressive American Catholic Council. “We’re at a crossroads of some sort.”

Or (was he really a New York Times editor?) Bill Keller:

This is not a bastion of enlightenment. Don’t expect a Vatican Spring.

Or Salon, talking to people who don’t understand that faith on your terms is pretty much worthless:

“It would be refreshing for the Catholic Church to take a realistic view on contraception and abortion. But I don’t see that happening no matter who is chosen to be the next pope. There are many valid spiritual paths one can choose. Catholics have a choice.”

Mark Shea puts them in their place:

This is the hour when having a heirarchy [sic] of ents that is totally out of touch with global media opinion and tragically unhip really pays off. Global media will have almost zero impact on the outcome of the conclave. And words cannot express how grateful I am for that.

Ya see, any church that defines its morals based on popular opinion or government edict ain’t a church worth following. Do I struggle with Church teachings? Of course. If you ain’t strugglin’, you ain’t trying. The heart likes to oppose the head. But I take comfort from the systematic, coherent, deliberate approach to theology that the Church offers. I’d rather have that than a do-what-you-feel faith any day.

Advertisements

2 responses to “Yeah, good luck with that, Church dissenters

  1. The leadership of our church needs to be in touch with the signs of our times.

    Critics of the Church need to be in touch with God.

    It would be refreshing for the Catholic Church to take a realistic view on contraception and abortion.

    It would be refreshing for secularists to take a spiritual view on contraception and abortion.

    As to Mark Shea, spot on!

    Comment edited to fix coding. The wording is intact.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s